Tom Faletti
October 24, 2026
Read John 16:4b-11 The Holy Spirit has some very particular work to do in the world
In verse 5, Jesus says that none of the disciples are now asking him where he is going. Earlier, in John 13:36, Peter had asked that question as part of claiming that he would follow Jesus even unto death. In 14:5, Thomas had said, “We do not know where you are going. How can we know the way?” Scholars do not agree on how to explain this. The most common ideas are that the disciples didn’t really want to know and weren’t trying to find out the answer when they raised the question before, or that John gathered material from various sources (the stories passed on by word of mouth) and chose not to reconcile the differences.
Why, in verse 7, does Jesus say it is better for them if he leaves than if he stays?
Do you agree? How would you explain to the disciples that Jesus is right in saying that it is better for them if he leaves? Or if you aren’t sure you agree, how do you think Jesus would explain further?
In verse 7, the Greek word Paraclete that Jesus uses for the Holy Spirit can mean “advocate” or “comforter” or “counselor” or “helper.” Regardless of which word better captures your sense of the Holy Spirit, why is the coming of the Holy Spirit so important for us?
People sometimes find verses 8-11 confusing. We need to understand the key verb, and then we need to understand the three things Jesus says the Holy Spirit does.
In verse 8, some translations say he (the Advocate, the Holy Spirit) will “convict the world,” others that he will “prove the world wrong,” and others that he will “convince the world.” “Convict” is misleading because we use that word for the point in a trial when a judge pronounces judgment, and that is not what this word means. This Greek word means “to cross-examine, question, for the purpose of disproving or reproving . . . to bring convincing proof” (Liddell and Scott, p. 249). The Holy Spirit effectively and successfully makes the case and provides convincing proof. But proof of what?
He will provide convincing proof of sin, righteousness, and judgment.
Verses 9-11 explain these 3 things the Holy Spirit will provide the convincing proof of:
Verse 9: Sin: The Holy Spirit will show people that their central sin is their failure to believe in Jesus. In what way is failure to believe in Jesus the root of all sin?
Verse 10: Righteousness: The Holy Spirit will show the world that even though Jesus died a shameful death, he is in fact righteous and the people who denounced him for healing on the Sabbath (John 5:16; 7:12; 9:16) were wrong. His righteousness is demonstrated by the fact that he has been raised back to life and now lives with the Father. How does Jesus’s return to the Father show that he is righteous?
Verse 11: Judgment: The Holy Spirit will condemn Satan, the ruler of this world, and all the evil and lies that he fosters. Why would one of the roles of the Holy Spirit be to provide the evidence to judge and condemn Satan?
These are not the roles people usually associate with the Holy Spirit. Which of these 3 roles strikes you as particularly important in our time?
Read John 16:12-15 The Holy Spirit comes to guide us to all truth
What does Jesus say in verse 12?
Jesus says he has more to teach them, but they cannot bear it now. The Greek word for “bear” has the same variety of meanings the English word “bear” has: to bear a burden, to carry an object such as a purse, to bear a child, to carry the cross.
Why can’t the disciples “bear” to hear the additional things Jesus wants to say to them?
There is a whole teaching about human psychology hidden in verse 12. What are some of the situations we might face where we can’t bear to hear what someone else might want to tell us?
What are some of the situations we might face where we can’t bear to hear everything that God might want to tell us?
Jesus is wise in his understanding of human nature. He knows we are not perfect. He doesn’t reject the disciples here, and he doesn’t reject us. He recognizes when we can’t “bear” to hear more, and he doesn’t reject us because we are weak. What does this tell you about Jesus’s place in your life when you are struggling, when you are facing difficult situations?
In verse 13, Jesus refers to the Holy Spirit as the Spirit of truth. Why is it important that the Holy Spirit guides us to the truth? (Look at what Jesus said in John 8:31-32 for one way to think about the importance of the truth.)
How do you picture the process by which the Holy Spirit guides us into all the truth? How does he do that?
How do you experience the Holy Spirit as the Spirit of truth?
In verses 13-15, Jesus assures the disciples that they won’t get a different story from the Holy Spirit than they have received from him: the Holy Spirit will speak what he receives from Jesus, who has revealed these things from the Father. This is a very trinitarian image: 3 Persons who are completely united. How does this help you envision the role and place of the Holy Spirit in your life?
Jesus told the disciples many things that would only happen later, after his death and resurrection. Verse 13 says that the Holy Spirit will declare the things that are to come, which means in part that he will help them recognize when these things are coming to pass. How does the Holy Spirit help us to recognize how the things that Jesus taught apply in our day?
How important is the Holy Spirit in your spiritual life?
How can you grow closer to the Holy Spirit?
Take a step back and consider this:
The Holy Spirit does not force himself[1] on us in a demonstration of power. He does not seek to scare us through spooky spectacle. We hear the Holy Spirit in the quiet spaces in our hearts where he guides us lovingly to the truth if we are open to hearing his voice.
Christians also speak of people who serve as prophetic voices, who speak the truth to people in positions of power or to a society as a whole. In keeping with John 16:8-9, these voices sometimes reprove a society or its leaders for their willingness to allow sin to pervade the society rather than adopting reforms that will bring the society in line with the teachings of Jesus. They may focus on the need to act in accordance with God’s love or peace or justice or concern for the poor and forgotten.
Not every interior voice is the Holy Spirit. We may be hearing what is merely our own thoughts. Not every prophetic voice in the public space comes from God. They may be motivated merely by their own human ideas or interests.
Where do you see people who are prophetic voices in your society today?
How do you discern whether they are guided by God and speaking from the Holy Spirit or not?
In what ways do you hear the interior voice of the Holy Spirit in your own heart?
How do you discern whether you are hearing God’s guidance or merely your own wants, hopes, or fears?
_____
[1] The Holy Spirit does not have a gender, but it is helpful to refer to the Holy Spirit using the pronoun “he.” The Bible sometimes uses “he” and sometimes uses “it” to refer to the Holy Spirit, but the male pronoun helps maintain the connection between God’s Son Jesus and the Holy Spirit. Acts of the Apostles refers to the Holy Spirit as “the Spirit of Jesus” (Acts 16:6-7) and Paul refers to the Holy Spirit as “the Spirit of Christ” (Rom. 8:9), “the Spirit of [God’s] Son” (Gal. 4:6), and “the Spirit of Jesus Christ” (Phil. 1:19). Using “he” for the Holy Spirit helps to affirm the unity that the Son and the Spirit share, as expressed in the Bible.
Bibliography
See John - Bibliography at https://www.faithexplored.com/john/bibliography.
Copyright © 2026, Tom Faletti (Faith Explored, www.faithexplored.com). This material may be reproduced in whole or in part without alteration, for nonprofit use, provided such reproductions are not sold and include this copyright notice or a similar acknowledgement that includes a reference to Faith Explored and www.faithexplored.com. See www.faithexplored.com for more materials like this.
